Skip to Content

How to Make an Offer on An Overpriced Investment Property

For Sale Sign in Front of Suburban Home

If you’re an investor in Brewer, you’re likely always looking for the next great bargain rental property. However, sometimes the property you’re interested in may not be listed at a favorable price or fair market value.

Negotiating the purchase of an overpriced home can be tricky. Still, with preparation, strategic thinking, and an understanding of negotiation dynamics, you can significantly increase your chances of getting a fair deal.

Negotiating a deal includes conducting market research, understanding seller motivations, making appealing offers, and knowing your limits. You have a higher chance of attaining a good outcome and securing an acceptable price if you negotiate properly.


Research the Current Market

A comparative market analysis helps gather objective information about recent sales, related properties, and trends. This study helps find differences between the asking price and the item’s real worth. It gives buyers a solid basis on which to negotiate the purchase of an overpriced property.

To learn about the local market, talk to real estate agents and look at sales records. Analyze related properties by looking at sale prices, features, location, condition, and market trends like average days on the market and big changes in property values. This thorough research gives you the tools you need to negotiate successfully.

Understanding the current real estate market can help you in a number of ways during negotiations. This study will be your guide and help you find problems or expensive parts of the property that could be used to justify a lower price.


Understand the Home Seller

If you know why the seller wants to sell their home, you can change how you negotiate, find places to meet in the middle, and adjust your methods to fit. When negotiating a good price, think about what they want, such as a quick sale or an emotional connection.

Talk to the seller or the agent in an open way to find out why they are selling. Ask them what made them decide what they did and if there were any specific events that affected their choice. Pay close attention to what they say and how they say it. Look into the history of the property and read public documents to learn more about the seller’s position.

Understanding the seller’s motives helps create a personalized strategy and fosters a cooperative atmosphere. It enables you to tailor your negotiation techniques, identify compromise opportunities, and increase the likelihood of finding a mutually beneficial solution.


Make an Appealing Offer

A firm price gets the seller’s attention and shows that the buyer is serious. It shows that you have carefully thought about how much the property is worth and that you want to make a fair deal. Making a unique offer increases your chances of getting a good deal and may even get the seller to change their price.

It should be competitive, well-structured, and backed by good reasoning to make an appealing deal. Offer a price that’s close to the fair market value but lower than the high asking price. Present the offer in a professional way with a written proposal that lists the terms and conditions. Include a personal message that shows your real interest in the property and any emotional or shared visions you have for it.

A compelling offer shows that you are a trustworthy bidder who wants to discuss in good faith. It is backed up by market research and has a personal touch, which makes it more likely to catch the seller’s attention and open the door for further conversation. An attractive offer looks at the value of the property in an unbiased way, which can lead to a reasonable counteroffer or helpful negotiations.


Consider Alternatives

Considering options is important if you want to increase the number of things you can negotiate. Looking into different conditions or concessions can help close price gaps and reach a solution that works for both parties. Being creative and willing to try different things will make it easier to reach a deal with the seller.

Discuss potential property repairs, inclusion of items, flexible closing dates, and shared responsibilities or expenses. Instead of just focusing on the price, it may be helpful to look into other choices.

By focusing on shared interests or values, both parties can create a situation where everyone wins, and the seller feels like they’ve gained more than just money. Also, thinking about other options makes it more likely that you’ll find a good answer, even if the first price talks are hard.


Be Patient and Know Your Limits

Don’t make hasty decisions or concessions during talks, as impatience can work against your best interests. Take the time to keep your mind clear and strong, which will increase the chances of a good result. It is important to know your limits so you can set guidelines and stay in charge of the negotiation process.

Before making any choices, you should carefully look at offers, counteroffers, and proposals. Let the other person say what they think by actively listening. Take breaks as needed to stay focused and clear.

Think about what you need, what you want, and what you can’t live without in terms of the property and its terms. Find your breaking point, which is the highest price or worst conditions beyond which you won’t go on.


Talk to experts to learn more and understand your limits. You can negotiate well and make choices that are in your best interests if you set and know your limits.

At Real Property Management Acadia, we offer rental property owners professional market analyses on potential properties and full-service management of rental homes. To learn more about what we have to offer, contact us or call us at 207-561-7482.


Originally published on May 5, 2021

We are pledged to the letter and spirit of U.S. policy for the achievement of equal housing opportunity throughout the Nation. See Equal Housing Opportunity Statement for more information.

The Neighborly Done Right Promise

The Neighborly Done Right Promise ® delivered by Real Property Management, a proud Neighborly company

When it comes to finding the right property manager for your investment property, you want to know that they stand behind their work and get the job done right – the first time. At Real Property Management we have the expertise, technology, and systems to manage your property the right way. We work hard to optimize your return on investment while preserving your asset and giving you peace of mind. Our highly trained and skilled team works hard so you can be sure your property's management will be Done Right.

Canada excluded. Services performed by independently owned and operated franchises.

See Full Details